===============================
File 6HCMP32.TXT
-------------------------------
Comparison of Detection Quality 
  of 32-Bit Scanning Engines: 
  (Win-98 / Win-NT / Win-2000)            
===============================
Formatted with non-proportional font (Courier)

The following tables summarize the respective detection rates of
products on different 32-bit platforms (Windows 98, Windows-NT, and
Windows-2000 respectively, concerning products with results on ALL
platforms). Products with identical detection quality for both 
instantiations of 32-bit engines are marked with "*".

Comparative tables:
-------------------
	Table Comp.M1v: Detection of Zoo Macro viruses
        Table Comp.M1f: Detection of Zoo Macro viral files
	Table Comp.M2v: Detection of ITW Macro viruses
	Table Comp.M2f: Detection of ITW Macro viral files
        Table Comp.M3m: Detection of Zoo Macro Malware

	Table Comp.S1v: Detection of Zoo Script viruses
        Table Comp.S1f: Detection of Zoo Script viral files
	Table Comp.S2v: Detection of ITW Script viruses
	Table Comp.S2f: Detection of ITW Script viral files
        Table Comp.S3m: Detection of Zoo Script Malware


Table Comp.M1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Viruses:
=======================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed     6762 100.0    6762 100.0    6762 100.0
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT         6566  97.1     ---   ---    6587  97.4       
AVA         6604  97.7    6604  97.7    6605  97.7       
AVG         6651  98.4    6651  98.4    6651  98.4      *
AVK         6762 100.0    6762 100.0    6762 100.0      *
AVP         6761 100.0    6761  100~    6761  100~      *
AVX         6703  99.1     ---   ---    6703  99.1      *
CMD         6760 100.0    6760  100~    6760  100~      *
DRW         6725  99.5    6725  99.5    6725  99.5      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---    6610  97.8      -
FPR         6760 100.0    6760  100~    6760  100~      *
FPW         6760 100.0    6760  100~    6760  100~      *
FSE         6762 100.0    6762 100.0    6762 100.0      *
IKA         6451  95.4     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO         6755  99.9    6755  99.9    6755  99.9      *
NAV         6726  99.5    6726  99.5    6731  99.5       
NVC         6751  99.8    6751  99.8    6751  99.8      *
PAV         6762 100.0    6762 100.0    6762 100.0      *
QHL            0   0.0     ---   ---       0   0.0      *
RAD         6726  99.5     ---   ---     ---   ---     (*)
RAV         6726  99.5    6726  99.5    6726  99.5      *
SCN         6762 100.0    6762 100.0    6762 100.0      *
VSP            1   0.0       1   0.~       1   0.~      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.M1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro viral objects:
=============================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed    21677 100.0%  21677 100.0%  21677 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT        20811  96.0     ---   ---   20853  96.2       
AVA        21202  97.8   21202  97.8   21206  97.8       
AVG        21387  98.7   21387  98.7   21387  98.7      *
AVK        21674 100.0   21674  100~   21674  100~      *
AVP        21673 100.0   21673  100~   21673  100~      *
AVX        21474  99.1     ---   ---   21474  99.1      *
CMD        21672 100.0   21672  100~   21672  100~      *
DRW        21574  99.5   21574  99.5   21574  99.5      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---   20971  96.7      -
FPR        21672 100.0   21672  100~   21672  100~      *
FPW        21672 100.0   21672  100~   21672  100~      *
FSE        21677 100.0   21677 100.0   21677 100.0      *
IKA        20723  95.6     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO        21651  99.9   21651  99.9   21651  99.9      *
NAV        21495  99.2   21495  99.2   21520  99.3       
NVC        21622  99.7   21622  99.7   21622  99.7      *
PAV        21674 100.0   21674  100~   21674  100~      *
QHL            0   0.0     ---   ---       0   0.0      *
RAD        21546  99.4     ---   ---     ---   ---     (*)
RAV        21545  99.4   21545  99.4   21545  99.4      *
SCN        21677 100.0   21677 100.0   21677 100.0      *
VSP            1   0.0       1   0.~       1   0.~      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.M2v: Detection Quality of ITW Macro Viruses:
=======================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed      143 100.0%    143 100.0%    143 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT          142  99.3     ---   ---     142  99.3      *
AVA          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
AVG          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
AVK          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
AVP          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
AVX          143 100.0     ---   ---     143 100.0      *
CMD          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
DRW          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---     140  97.9      -
FPR          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
FPW          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
FSE          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
IKA          142  99.3     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
NAV          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
NVC          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
PAV          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
QHL            0   0.0     ---   ---       0   0.0      *
RAD          143 100.0     ---   ---     ---   ---     (*)
RAV          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
SCN          143 100.0     143 100.0     143 100.0      *
VSP            0   0.0       0   0.0       0   0.0      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.M2f: Detection Quality of ITW Macro viral files:
==========================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed     1308 100.0%   1308 100.0%   1308 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT         1294  98.9     ---   ---    1294  98.9      *
AVA         1305  99.8    1305  99.8    1305  99.8      *
AVG         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
AVK         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
AVP         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
AVX         1308 100.0     ---   ---    1308 100.0      *
CMD         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
DRW         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---    1275  97.5      -
FPR         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
FPW         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
FSE         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
IKA         1299  99.3     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
NAV         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
NVC         1305  99.8    1305  99.8    1305  99.8      *
PAV         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
QHL            0   0.0     ---   ---       0   0.0      *
RAD         1302  99.5     ---   ---     ---   ---     (*)
RAV         1302  99.5    1302  99.5    1302  99.5      *
SCN         1308 100.0    1308 100.0    1308 100.0      *
VSP            0   0.0       0   0.0       0   0.0      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.M3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Macro Malware:
=======================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed      683 100.0%   683 100.0%     683 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT          606  88.7     ---   ---     612  89.6       
AVA          584  85.5     584  85.5     586  85.8       
AVG          584  85.5     584  85.5     584  85.5      *
AVK          682  99.9     682  99.9     682  99.9      *
AVP          682  99.9     682  99.9     682  99.9      *
AVX          630  92.2     ---   ---     630  92.2      *
CMD          676  99.0     676  99.0     676  99.0      *
DRW          622  91.1     622  91.1     622  91.1      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---     580  84.9      -
FPR          676  99.0     676  99.0     676  99.0      *
FPW          676  99.0     676  99.0     676  99.0      *
FSE          682  99.9     682  99.9     682  99.9      *
IKA          612  89.6     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO          653  95.6     647  94.7     653  95.6       
NAV          596  87.3     596  87.3     596  87.3      *
NVC          660  96.6     660  96.6     660  96.6      *
PAV          683 100.0     683 100.0     683 100.0      *
QHL            0   0.0     ---   ---       0   0.0      *
RAD          663  97.1     ---   ---     ---   ---     (*)
RAV          662  96.9     663  97.1     663  97.1     
SCN          683 100.0     683 100.0     683 100.0      *
VSP            1   0.1       1   0.1       1   0.1      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.S1v: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Viruses:
========================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed      588 100.0%    588 100.0%    588 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT          481  81.8     ---   ---     481  81.8      *
AVA          174  29.6     174  29.6     198  33.7       
AVG          370  62.9     370  62.9     370  62.9      *
AVK          588 100.0     588 100.0     588 100.0      *
AVP          588 100.0     588 100.0     588 100.0      *
AVX          412  70.1     ---   ---     412  70.1       
CMD          552  93.9     548  93.2     552  93.9       
DRW          561  95.4     561  95.4     561  95.4      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---     429  73.0      -
FPR          558  94.9     556  94.6     556  94.6       
FPW          556  94.6     556  94.6     556  94.6      *
FSE          588 100.0     588 100.0     588 100.0      *
IKA          457  77.7     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO          559  95.1     552  93.9     559  95.1       
NAV          554  94.2     554  94.2     554  94.2      *
NVC          537  91.3     537  91.3     537  91.3      *
PAV          588 100.0     588 100.0     588 100.0      *
QHL            1   0.2     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
RAD          485  82.5     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
RAV            1   0.2     485  82.5     485  82.5     (*)  
SCN          587  99.8     587  99.8     587  99.8      *
VSP          494  84.0     494  84.0     494  84.0      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.S1f: Detection Quality of Zoo Script viral files:
============================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed     1079 100.0%   1079 100.0%   1079 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT          835  77.4     ---   ---     837  77.6       
AVA          380  35.2     380  35.2     444  41.1       
AVG          727  67.4     727  67.4     727  67.4      *
AVK         1079 100.0    1079 100.0    1079 100.0      *
AVP         1079 100.0    1079 100.0    1079 100.0      *
AVX          730  67.7     ---   ---     730  67.7      * 
CMD          987  91.5     980  90.8     987  91.5       
DRW          992  91.9     992  91.9     992  91.9      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---     753  69.8      -
FPR          994  92.1     991  91.8     991  91.8       
FPW          989  91.7     989  91.7     989  91.7      *
FSE         1076  99.7    1076  99.7    1077  99.8       
IKA          812  75.3     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO         1022  94.7     995  92.2    1022  94.7       
NAV          984  91.2     984  91.2     984  91.2      *
NVC          960  89.0     960  89.0     960  89.0      *
PAV         1079 100.0    1079 100.0    1076  99.7       
QHL            1   0.1     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
RAD          800  74.1     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
RAV            1   0.1     800  74.1     800  74.1     (*)  
SCN         1077  99.8    1077  99.8    1077  99.8      *
VSP          835  77.4     835  77.4     835  77.4      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.S2v: Detection Quality of ITW Script Viruses:
========================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed       19 100.0%     19 100.0%     19 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT           19 100.0     ---   ---      19 100.0      *
AVA           18  94.7      18  94.7      18  94.7      *
AVG           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
AVK           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
AVP           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
AVX           19 100.0     ---   ---      19 100.0      *
CMD           19 100.0      18  94.7      19 100.0       
DRW           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---      10  52.6       
FPR           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
FPW           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
FSE           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
IKA           18  94.7     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
NAV           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
NVC           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
PAV           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
QHL            1   5.3     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
RAD           18  94.7     ---   ---     ---   ---     (*)
RAV            0   0.0      18  94.7      18  94.7    
SCN           19 100.0      19 100.0      19 100.0      *
VSP           17  89.5      17  89.5      17  89.5      *
-----------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.S2f: Detection Quality of ITW Script viral files:
============================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed      110 100.0%    110 100.0%    110 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT          109  99.1     ---   ---     109  99.1      *
AVA           99  90.0      99  90.0     100  90.9       
AVG          107  97.3     107  97.3     107  97.3      *
AVK          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *
AVP          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *
AVX          110 100.0     ---   ---     110 100.0      *
CMD          109  99.1     108  98.2     109  99.1       
DRW          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---      72  65.5      -
FPR          109  99.1     109  99.1     109  99.1      *
FPW          109  99.1     109  99.1     109  99.1      *
FSE          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *      
IKA          101  91.8     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *
NAV          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *
NVC          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *
PAV          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *       
QHL            1   0.9     ---   ---     ---   ---      - 
RAD          106  96.4     ---   ---     ---   ---     (*)
RAV            0   0.0     107  97.3     107  97.3     
SCN          110 100.0     110 100.0     110 100.0      *
VSP           87  79.1      87  79.1      87  79.1      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.


Table Comp.S3m: Detection Quality of Zoo Script Malware:
========================================================
            ====== Detection Quality =========     W32 results
Scanner    Win-NT   %    Win-2k   %    Win-98   %     match
--------------------------------------------------------------
Testbed       30 100.0%     30 100.0%     30 100.0%
--------------------------------------------------------------
ANT            0   0.0     ---   ---       0   0.0      *
AVA          ---   ---     ---   ---       0   0.0      -
AVG            5  16.7       5  16.7       5  16.7      *
AVK           30 100.0      30 100.0      30 100.0      *
AVP           30 100.0      30 100.0      30 100.0      *
AVX            3  10.0     ---   ---       3  10.0      *
CMD           16  53.3      16  53.3      16  53.3      *
DRW            9  30.0       9  30.0       9  30.0      *
DSE          ---   ---     ---   ---      23  76.7      -
FPR           16  53.3      16  53.3      16  53.3      *
FPW           16  53.3      16  53.3      16  53.3      *
FSE           30 100.0      30 100.0      30 100.0      *
IKA            8  26.7     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
INO           19  63.3      19  63.3      19  63.3      *
NAV           11  36.7      11  36.7      11  36.7      *
NVC            2   6.7       2   6.7       2   6.7      *
PAV           30 100.0      30 100.0      30 100.0      *
QHL            1   3.3     ---   ---     ---   ---      -
RAD           25  83.3     ---   ---     ---   ---     (*)
RAV            0   0.0      25  83.3      25  83.3     (*) 
SCN           30 100.0      30 100.0      30 100.0      *
VSP            6  20.0       6  20.0       6  20.0      *
--------------------------------------------------------------
(*) Remark: concerning RAD/RAV, see 8problms.txt.







